Recipe Box0

Ingredient · Agaricus bisporus (cultivated mushroom)

Cremini Mushrooms

Brown, firm mushrooms that are the mid-stage of the same species as white button and portobello. They’re meatier and more savory than white buttons. For deep browning, use a wide hot pan, don’t crowd, and wait to salt until the mushrooms have released moisture and started to brown.

Recipes2
SeasonSold year-round
Keeps4 to 7 dayswhole, unwashed, fridge crisper in a paper bag or the store tray loosely covered
AllergensNot a major US allergen

Cremini Mushrooms recipes

What to cook with cremini mushrooms

2 recipes

Forms and products

Which cremini mushrooms should you buy?

FormTypeBest for
WholePreparationRoasting, stuffing, skewers
SlicedPreparationSautés, pasta, pizza
QuarteredPreparationRoasting and stews; meaty bite
ChoppedPreparationSauces, fillings, meat mixes
Pre slicedProductWeeknight sautés; use within 1 to 2 days after opening. Check for dryness and intact edges

Baby bella / cremini

Brown, firm caps. More flavor than white buttons; great for browning.

Portobello (mature stage)

Same species grown larger. Open gills, bigger caps, deeper, earthier flavor.

White button (younger stage)

Same species picked earlier. Milder flavor; cooks the same.

Buy and store

How to pick and store cremini mushrooms

At the store

  • Choose caps that are firm, dry, and smooth with tightly closed gills.
  • Avoid slimy surfaces, dark wet spots, or strong fishy/acidic odors.
  • Stems should be plump, not hollow or mushy.
  • Prepacked trays are fine. If wrapped tight, slit the plastic so they can breathe at home.
How it's keptWhereAbout how long
Whole, unwashedFridge crisper in a paper bag or the store tray loosely covered4 to 7 days
Sliced, unwashedFridge in a paper towel-lined container, lid ajar1 to 2 days
CookedFridge, airtight container3 to 4 days
Frozen (cooked)Freeze after sautéing until moisture is off10 to 12 months

Food safety. Throw out mushrooms that are slimy, sticky, moldy, very soft, or smell sour. Dark, wet patches and wrinkles mean quality is declining.

Food safety. You can rinse mushrooms quickly just before cooking. Don’t soak. Dry well so they brown, and don’t wash before storing.

Advertisement

Prep

How to prep cremini mushrooms

The techniques this calls for, and the tools that make them easier.

All techniques →

Techniques

Clean MushroomsSlice MushroomsSaute MushroomsRoast MushroomsBrown Mushrooms

Tools that help

SkilletWide surface to brown without steaming
Sheet PanEven roasting for big batches
Chefs KnifeClean slices without crushing

Equipment links may become affiliate links, always labeled as such.

Substitutes

Out of cremini mushrooms? Use this instead

SubstituteFor 1 mushroomWhat to know
White Button Mushrooms8 oz1:1 by weight. Milder flavor; brown well for more savor.
Portobello Mushrooms8 ozSame species. Trim gills if you want less dark color in sauces.
Shiitake Mushrooms8 ozMeatier, woodsy flavor. Remove tough stems; great in sautés and pasta.
Oyster Mushrooms8 ozTender, delicate. Brown quickly; less intense than cremini.
Canned Mushrooms8 ozUse one 4-ounce can, drained, to replace 8 ounces of fresh mushrooms. Drain and pat dry; they have a softer texture and milder taste.

Nutrition and allergens

Nutrition per mushroom

Per mushroom (15 g)

Calories5
Carbohydrates1 g
Protein0.2 g
Fat0.1 g
Fiber0.6 g (2% DV)
Sodium1 mg (1% DV)

Calculated from USDA FoodData Central.

Allergens and diets

  • Not a major US allergen
    Not one of the nine major allergens. Mushroom allergy or intolerance exists; stop eating if you react.
  • Vegetarian
  • Vegan
  • Fodmap: variable
    Mushrooms contain polyols (mannitol). Some people tolerate small servings better or choose canned, well-drained mushrooms. Follow your plan.
  • Blends
    Seasoned or marinated mushrooms can include added sodium, dairy, soy, or gluten. Read labels.

Flavor pairings

What goes with cremini mushrooms

FAQ

Cremini Mushrooms questions

Can I substitute white mushrooms for cremini mushrooms?

Yes. Swap 1:1 by weight or volume. White buttons are the same species, picked younger. They’re milder, so brown them well and season a touch more. In most sautés, soups, and pasta sauces you won’t need to change the method or time.

What is the flavor profile of cremini mushrooms?

Savory, earthy, and slightly nutty, with more umami than white buttons. When well browned they pick up roasted, meaty notes. If you add a splash of soy sauce or balsamic as they finish, the umami reads even deeper.

What does "cremini" mean?

It’s a market name for the brown, mid-maturity stage of Agaricus bisporus - the same species as white button (younger) and portobello (older). You’ll also see “crimini” and “baby bella.” They’re all referring to the same brown mushroom stage.

What is the difference between cremini mushrooms and portobello mushrooms?

They’re the same species. Cremini are smaller with closed gills and a firmer bite. Portobellos are fully mature with open gills, larger caps, and a deeper, earthier flavor. Cook them the same way; remove portobello gills if you want less dark color in sauces.

How long will cremini mushrooms last in the refrigerator?

Whole, unwashed cremini stored in a paper bag in the fridge keep about 4 to 7 days. Sliced mushrooms keep 1 to 2 days. Cooked mushrooms keep 3 to 4 days. If they turn slimy, very soft, or smell sour, throw them out.

What is the best way to store fresh mushrooms to keep them fresh?

Refrigerate unwashed mushrooms in a paper bag or their tray loosely covered so they can breathe. Avoid sealed plastic. Don’t wash before storing. If pre-sliced, transfer to a container lined with paper towels and leave the lid slightly ajar to vent moisture.