Recipe Box0

Ingredient · Nightshade family (Solanaceae)

Potatoes

Starchy root vegetables. Yukon Gold are medium-starch and naturally creamy; russets are high-starch and fluffy. For mashed potatoes, use Yukon Gold for creamy, or russets for fluffy. Many cooks like a 50/50 mix.

Recipes1
SeasonPeak Sep-Feb; sold year-round
KeepsUp to 2 monthswhole, unwashed, cool (45° to 55°F)
AllergensNot a major US allergen

Season in the US · dark = peak harvest, light = in stores

Harvested late summer to fall and stored in climate-controlled facilities, so you’ll find them year-round.

Close-up of several whole russet and Yukon Gold potatoes on a dark wooden surface with one halved to show the interior, lit by soft back-left window light.

Potatoes recipes

What to cook with potatoes

1 recipe

Forms and products

Which potatoes should you buy?

FormTypeBest for
ScrubbedPreparationRoasting, baking, boiling with skins on
PeeledPreparationMashing, purées, soups; more even texture
Chunks 1½ inchPreparationBoiling for mash or potato salad; cooks evenly
Diced ½ inchPreparationHash, soups, stews; faster cook
WedgesPreparationRoasting and air-frying
ShreddedPreparationLatkes and hash browns; squeeze out moisture
Baked wholePreparationRussets for classic baked potatoes
MashedPreparationYukon Gold for naturally creamy; russet for lighter, fluffier mash
Instant flakesProductQuick mash or to thicken soups; follow the label. Not a 1:1 swap by weight with fresh potatoes
Frozen friesProductConvenience; bake or air-fry from frozen

Yukon Gold (yellow)

Medium starch and moisture. Buttery flavor, thin gold skin. Great for mashing, roasting, and soups. Holds shape better than russets when boiled.

Russet (Idaho)

High starch, low moisture. Thick netted brown skin, white flesh. Best for baking, fluffy mash, and extra-crispy fries.

Red

Waxy, low starch. Thin red skin, creamy flesh. Holds shape in salads and roasts; not as fluffy for mash.

White

All-purpose. Thin tan skin, mild flavor. Works across methods; texture sits between red and Yukon Gold.

Klondike Goldust (brand/variety)

A branded yellow potato similar to Yukon Gold in use and texture, but not the same named variety.

Buy and store

How to pick and store potatoes

At the store

  • Choose firm potatoes that feel heavy for their size with smooth skin. Avoid cuts, soft spots, or wrinkling.
  • Skip green-tinged or heavily sprouted potatoes; they taste bitter. Small, fresh sprouts can be trimmed deeply.
  • Pick russets for fluffy baked potatoes and fries. Pick Yukon Gold for creamy mash, roasting, and soups.
  • Buy similar-sized potatoes so they cook in the same time.
How it's keptWhereAbout how long
Whole, unwashedCool (45° to 55°F), dark, dry, well-ventilated spotUp to 2 months
Whole, room temp pantryDark, dry spot away from onions and sunlight1 to 2 weeks
Cut, rawFridge, submerged in cold water, coveredUp to 24 hours; change water if cloudy
Cooked potatoes or mashFridge, airtight container3 to 4 days
Cooked mash or baked potato, frozenFreeze airtightUp to 10 months

Food safety. Green skin and long sprouts can indicate higher solanine, which tastes bitter and can upset your stomach. Trim small sprouts and eyes deeply. Discard potatoes that are very green, bitter, or heavily sprouted.

Food safety. Refrigerate cooked potatoes within 2 hours. Reheat leftovers to 165°F (74°C).

Food safety. Refrigerating raw potatoes can make them sweeter and brown faster when fried. If refrigerated, let them sit a day or two at room temp before cooking.

Advertisement

Prep

How to prep potatoes

The techniques this calls for, and the tools that make them easier.

All techniques →

Techniques

Boil PotatoesMash PotatoesBake PotatoesRoast PotatoesPan FryAir FryParboil Potatoes

Tools that help

Potato MasherQuick, rustic mash
RicerUltra-smooth, lump-free mash
Vegetable PeelerFast, safe peeling
Sheet PanRoasting with space for browning
Large PotBoiling without crowding
ColanderDrain quickly and fully

Equipment links may become affiliate links, always labeled as such.

Substitutes

Out of potatoes? Use this instead

SubstituteFor 1 mediumWhat to know
Red Potatoes1 mediumGood in soups and roasts. For mash, expect a creamier but less fluffy texture.
White Potatoes1 mediumAll-purpose swap for most methods.
Sweet Potatoes1 mediumDifferent flavor and sweetness; works for baking or mashing with adjusted seasonings.
Cauliflowerabout 2 cups floretsFor lighter “mash.” Steam well, drain thoroughly, then purée with butter or olive oil.
Instant Mashed Potatoesper label for 1 servingFast standby for mash or to thicken soups. Flavor is different from fresh.

Flavor pairings

What goes with potatoes

FAQ

Potatoes questions

Should I use Russet or Gold potatoes for mashed potatoes?

Use Yukon Gold for naturally creamy, rich mash that holds together, or russets for a lighter, fluffier mash. Many cooks mix them 50/50 for the best of both. Cut in 1½-inch chunks, start in cold salted water, and add warm dairy and butter.

Should you wrap potatoes in foil to bake?

No, not if you want a crisp skin. Bake russets unwrapped at 425°F on a rack or sheet until a skewer slides through easily, 45 to 60 minutes. Foil traps steam, softening the skin. If you do use foil for holding, unwrap to prevent sogginess.

Should I peel potatoes before boiling?

It’s up to you. Skins add flavor and nutrients and help prevent waterlogging. For smooth mash, peel after boiling: simmer whole, drain, let steam-dry, then slip off skins. For potato salad, leave skins on or peel before; keep sizes even either way.

What is the secret to boiling potatoes perfectly?

Start cut potatoes in cold, well-salted water so they cook evenly. Simmer gently, don’t hard-boil. Cook until a knife meets little resistance. Drain and let them steam-dry in the pot for a few minutes so they don’t turn watery or gluey in mash.

What is a common mistake when making mashed potatoes?

Overworking them. Mashing in a food processor or mixing too long releases starch and makes gluey mash. Use a masher for rustic or a ricer for smooth. Let potatoes steam-dry, warm your butter and dairy, and season with salt while cooking the potatoes.

Can you use Russet instead of Yukon Gold potatoes?

Yes. Russets swap well in mash, bakes, and fries. Expect a fluffier, drier texture than Yukon Gold. If you want creamier results, add a bit more butter or dairy, or mix russets with some Yukon Gold.

Are store-brand 'gold potatoes' the same as Yukon Gold?

No, not always. Yukon Gold is a specific variety of potato. Many stores sell other yellow-fleshed potatoes simply labeled 'gold potatoes' or under a store brand. While they are good all-purpose substitutes for Yukon Golds, they are different varieties and may have slight differences in texture or flavor.