Ingredient · Fats and oils
Vegetable Shortening
A solid fat made from vegetable oils. Neutral flavor, 100% fat, and plastic at room temperature, so it makes tender, flaky pie crusts and helps cookies keep their shape. For baking math: 1 cup = 184 g; 1 stick = 1 cup = about 184 g. For pie crust, many bakers use half butter, half shortening.

Vegetable Shortening recipes
What to cook with vegetable shortening
1 recipe
Forms and products
Which vegetable shortening should you buy?
| Form | Type | Equals 1 cup | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sticks | Product | 1 stick = 1 cup = about 184 g | Easy measuring for cookies, biscuits and pie crusts |
| Tub | Product | Scoop and level: 1 cup = 184 g | Bulk baking; measure by weight or water-displacement |
| Butter flavored | Product | Same measure as regular | Adds buttery aroma to cookies and frostings; still behaves like shortening |
| Chilled | Preparation | Same measure as regular | Cut into flour for extra-flaky pie crust and biscuits |
| Melted | Preparation | Same measure by weight | Quick breads and some frostings; cool slightly before mixing with eggs |
All-vegetable shortening
Most supermarket brands; neutral taste, firm at room temp. Now typically nonhydrogenated and labeled 0 g trans fat per serving.
Butter-flavored shortening
All-vegetable base with added flavor and color. Bakes like regular shortening with a buttery aroma.
Palm shortening
Made from palm oil fractions. Naturally solid without hydrogenation; clean flavor and good for high-heat frying.
Buy and store
How to pick and store vegetable shortening
At the store
- Choose a sealed can, tub, or sticks with a distant best-by date; fresher fat tastes cleaner.
- Avoid packages that smell paint-like or soapy when opened - those are signs of rancidity.
- Sticks are easiest to measure; tubs are most economical for frequent baking.
- Check the label for type of oil, saturated fat, and whether it’s nonhydrogenated and 0 g trans fat per serving.
| How it's kept | Where | About how long |
|---|---|---|
| Unopened can/tub or sticks | Pantry, cool and dark | Up to 2 years; check best-by date |
| Opened tub or unwrapped sticks | Pantry, tightly covered; or fridge for firmer texture | Up to 1 year in the pantry; or fridge for firmer texture |
| Frozen | Freezer, airtight, portioned | Up to 2 years; thaw in fridge before use |
| Measured portions | Chill or freeze pre-weighed chunks | Match the parent storage time |
Food safety. Old shortening can turn rancid. If it smells like paint, soap, or crayons, or tastes bitter, throw it out.
Prep
How to use vegetable shortening
The techniques this calls for, and the tools that make them easier.
Techniques
Tools that help
Equipment links may become affiliate links, always labeled as such.
Substitutes
Out of vegetable shortening? Use this instead
| Substitute | For 1 cup | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Butter | 1 cup | Use for 1 cup shortening in most baking. Butter adds flavor but more water; cookies spread more and crusts are less flaky. |
| Refined Coconut Oil | 1 cup (measured solid) | Closest plant-based solid fat. Use refined (neutral) for flavor; unrefined tastes like coconut. |
| Lard | 1 cup | Excellent for flaky pie crust and frying. Distinct pork aroma; not vegetarian. |
| Margarine | 1 cup | Works in cookies and bars. Like butter, it contains water; expect a bit more spread. |
| Ghee | 1 cup | 100% butterfat with buttery flavor. Softer at room temp; chill for cut-in pastry work. |
Nutrition and allergens
Nutrition per cup
Per cup (184 g)
| Calories | 1627 |
| Carbohydrates | 0 g |
| Protein | 0 g |
| Fat | 184 g |
| Fiber | 0 g (1% DV) |
| Sodium | 7 mg (1% DV) |
| Vitamin C | 0 mg (1% DV) |
Calculated from USDA FoodData Central.
Allergens and diets
- Not a major US allergen
Not one of the nine major allergens. Many brands use soybean and/or palm oil; some butter-flavored versions may contain milk-derived flavorings. Check labels if avoiding soy or dairy. - Vegan: varies
All-vegetable shortening is typically vegan; butter-flavored versions may not be. Read the label. - Kosher: varies
Certification varies by brand; check the symbol. - Fodmap: low
Pure fats contain no FODMAP carbohydrates.
Flavor pairings
What goes with vegetable shortening
FAQ
Vegetable Shortening questions
Is Crisco vegetable shortening healthier than butter?
They’re different fats. Shortening is 100% fat with no water; butter is about 80% fat with water and milk solids. Most modern shortenings are nonhydrogenated and 0 g trans fat per serving. Butter has more flavor but also cholesterol. For health questions, compare labels for saturated fat and choose what fits your diet.
How much butter does 1/2 cup of shortening equal?
Use ½ cup of butter to replace ½ cup of shortening. Butter’s water changes texture: cookies spread more, cakes may be a bit denser, and pie crust is less flaky. If the dough seems soft, chill it before baking.
What is the best alternative to vegetable shortening?
Refined coconut oil is the closest plant-based swap because it’s solid at room temperature and neutral when refined. For pie crust, many bakers also like lard. Butter works in most recipes but changes spread and flakiness. Match the fat’s firmness to the job.
What happens if you replace shortening with butter?
Expect more flavor, more spread in cookies, and less flaky pie crust. Butter’s water (about 16–18%) turns to steam and can make cakes a touch denser if the batter emulsifies poorly. To help, chill doughs before baking and avoid overmixing batters.
How long can I keep shortening in the fridge?
Opened shortening keeps for up to 1 year in a cool, dark pantry if tightly covered. You can also store it in the fridge, which keeps it firmer. If it smells like paint, soap, or crayons, or tastes bitter, it’s rancid - discard it. You can also freeze it for up to 2 years.
Is shortening the same as Crisco?
Crisco is a leading brand of vegetable shortening. “Shortening” is the product category: solid fats used for baking and frying. Many stores sell their own brand; labels vary by oil blend (often soybean and/or palm), flavoring, and packaging (tub or sticks).

