Recipe Box0

Ingredient · Plant-based fats

Plant-Based Butter

A dairy-free butter alternative made from plant oils and water, with emulsifiers and salt (optional). It cooks and bakes like butter when you pick the right style. For baking, use stick-style plant butter with about 79%–82% fat. Tubs have more water and can make cookies spread or cakes dense.

SeasonSold year-round
KeepsFollow the date on the packagesticks (unopened), fridge
AllergensNot a major US allergen
Unwrapped block of plant-based butter on a wooden board with two sliced pats, bright natural light

Forms and products

Which plant-based butter should you buy?

FormTypeEquals 1 tbspBest for
Stick unsaltedProduct1 tbsp per marked lineBaking and recipes that specify salt separately
Stick saltedProduct1 tbsp per marked lineTable use, finishing, quick sautés; reduce added salt
Tub spreadProduct1 tbsp ≈ 14 gSpreading, finishing hot vegetables; not ideal for creaming in baking
WhippedProduct1 tbsp ≈ 10 gSpreading; measure by weight for baking
MeltedPreparation1 tbsp melted = 1 tbsp solidDrizzling, roasting, pan sauces; measure, then melt

Olive oil blend

Neutral to olive-fruity flavor; good for sautéing and general cooking.

Avocado oil blend

Mild, high unsaturated fat. Works for cooking and baking.

Coconut oil blend

Firmer when cold; rich flavor that shows in frostings and shortbread.

Soy-based

Common, neutral flavor and reliable baking performance. Check for soy allergen.

Palm-oil-free

Uses blends like shea, cocoa, or coconut with liquid oils; chosen to avoid palm.

Buy and store

How to pick and store plant-based butter

At the store

  • For baking, choose stick-style with about 79%–82% fat; it creams and laminates like dairy butter.
  • Pick unsalted for control. Use salted for table use and quick sautés; cut added salt in the recipe.
  • If avoiding certain ingredients, check labels for soy, coconut, nuts, pea protein, or sesame.
  • If palm oil matters to you, look for palm-free or sustainably sourced palm on the label.
How it's keptWhereAbout how long
Sticks (unopened)FridgeFollow the date on the package
Sticks (opened)Fridge, wrapped airtightBest quality for several weeks; follow the date
Tubs (opened)Fridge, lid onBest quality for several weeks; keep clean utensils
Frozen sticksFreezer, airtightQuality best within a few months; thaw in the fridge
Room temperatureCounter, coveredLimit to 2 hours total per USDA guidance for perishable foods

Food safety. Plant-based butter is perishable. Keep it refrigerated. Per USDA guidance, don’t leave perishable foods out for more than 2 hours (1 hour above 90°F/32°C).

Food safety. Many brands contain soy, coconut (a tree nut per FDA), nuts, sesame, or pea protein. Always check labels; formulas change.

Advertisement

Prep

How to use plant-based butter

The techniques this calls for, and the tools that make them easier.

All techniques →

Techniques

Soften ButterMelt ButterCream Butter and SugarPan SauceRoast Vegetables

Tools that help

SaucepanFor melting and pan sauces
Stand MixerCreaming with sugar for cookies and cakes
Hand MixerBeating frostings and batters
Pastry CutterCutting into flour for biscuits and pie crusts

Equipment links may become affiliate links, always labeled as such.

Substitutes

Out of plant-based butter? Use this instead

SubstituteFor 1 tbspWhat to know
Butter1 tbspWorks in most recipes if dairy is acceptable. For salted butter, reduce added salt.
Olive Oil1 tbspGood for sautéing and roasting. In baking, use for focaccia or olive oil cakes, not creamed cookies.
Coconut Oil1 tbspSolid at room temp; closer to butter’s structure. Adds coconut note; good in pie crusts and shortbread.
Vegetable Shortening1 tbspNeutral and solid. Helps flakiness in pie crusts; cookies spread less. Lacks butter flavor; add a pinch of salt.
Canola Oil1 tbspNeutral choice for cooking and quick breads. Not for creaming methods; batters may be denser.

Flavor pairings

What goes with plant-based butter

FAQ

Plant-Based Butter questions

Is there a dairy free alternative to butter?

Yes. Plant-based butter (also called vegan butter) is a dairy-free alternative that cooks and bakes much like dairy butter. For the closest baking results, choose stick-style with about 79%–82% fat. For cooking, olive oil or avocado oil work well in a 1:1 swap by tablespoons.

Which is better, regular butter or plant-based butter?

It depends on your needs. For dairy-free or vegan cooking, plant-based butter is the clear choice. In baking, stick-style plant butter performs closest to dairy butter. For nutrition, compare labels: choose options higher in unsaturated fat and lower in saturated fat and sodium for everyday use.

Which butter is best for dairy free?

For baking, use stick-style plant butter labeled around 79%–82% fat; it creams and holds structure. For spreading and cooking, tubs are fine but often have more water. Pick unsalted for recipe control, or salted for table use. Check labels for allergens like soy or coconut.

Is plant-based butter the same thing as margarine?

They’re related but not identical. Both are water-in-oil emulsions made from plant fats. Modern plant-based butters aim to match butter’s fat level and behavior, often in sticks for baking. Margarine can be lower fat or whipped, which won’t cream the same. Read fat % and form.

Should plant-based butter be refrigerated?

Yes. Keep sticks and tubs refrigerated. Soften on the counter for 20 to 60 minutes before baking. Follow the package date for overall shelf life. For longer storage, freeze sticks airtight and thaw in the fridge. As with any perishable, limit time at room temperature to 2 hours total.

Can you substitute butter for plant-based butter?

Usually yes, 1:1 by tablespoons or sticks. In baking, match the form: use dairy butter where a recipe used stick-style plant butter. If swapping salted for unsalted (in either direction), adjust added salt. Expect slight flavor differences; taste and tweak seasonings.

Is plant-based butter healthy?

It depends on the ingredients and your dietary needs. Plant-based butters are made from various oils, so their nutrition profiles differ. To choose one that fits your goals, check the nutrition label for saturated fat, sodium, and total calories. Many are made with heart-healthy unsaturated fats from olive or avocado oil, but others use coconut or palm oil, which are high in saturated fat.